Part 4 — “I Begged Her to Take You”
“I begged her to take you—because your father was going to kill you.”
Sarah stared at the elderly woman.
Nobody moved.
Even the wind across Blackwater Lake seemed to disappear.
“My father?” Sarah whispered.
The woman nodded, tears running down her face.
Sarah looked at Helen—the woman she had called Mom her entire life.
Then back at the stranger.
“Who are you?”
The woman pressed a trembling hand against her chest.
“My name is Evelyn.”
Sarah waited.
Evelyn’s voice broke.
“And I gave birth to you thirty-six years ago.”
Sarah felt David move closer, ready to catch her if she collapsed.
Michael still held Lily near him.
Helen stood several feet away, crying silently.
Sarah looked at Evelyn.
“You’re saying you’re my mother?”
“Yes.”
“And you gave me away?”
Evelyn closed her eyes.
“Yes.”
Sarah laughed bitterly.
“Wonderful.”
“Sarah—”
“Don’t call me Sarah. Apparently, you named me Emily.”
Evelyn flinched.
Sarah’s eyes filled with tears.
“I woke up this morning believing my biggest problem was finding out whether my husband was alive. Now he’s standing over there, my daughter’s biological father is standing here, my mother isn’t my mother, my name apparently isn’t my name, and you’re telling me my biological father wanted me dead.”
She wiped her face.
“So somebody needs to start telling the truth.”
Michael nodded.
“All of it.”
Sarah looked directly at Evelyn.
“Start with my father.”
Evelyn’s expression changed.
“His name was Richard Hale.”
Helen lowered her eyes.
David whispered, “I’ve heard that name.”
Everyone looked at him.
“Where?”
“Michael’s files.”
Michael nodded.
“Richard Hale owned the medical company connected to Sarah’s childhood treatment.”
Sarah’s stomach tightened.
“My father owned the clinic?”
“Not exactly,” Michael said. “He financed it.”
Evelyn whispered, “Because he needed control over your medical records.”
Sarah stared at her.
“Why?”
Evelyn looked toward Lily.
“Because of what you inherited from him.”
Sarah’s heart began pounding.
“What did I inherit?”
Nobody answered immediately.
Sarah’s voice rose.
“WHAT?”
Michael stepped forward.
“A genetic mutation.”
Sarah stared at him.
“The one connected to my cancer?”
“Yes.”
Sarah’s hand moved unconsciously toward her hospital gown.
Evelyn began crying.
“Your father carried it. His mother died young. His sister died young. When I became pregnant, Richard became obsessed with whether you had inherited it.”
Sarah shook her head.
“People don’t kill babies because they might develop cancer.”
“No.”
Evelyn looked terrified even after all these years.
“That wasn’t why.”
“Then why?”
“Because Richard had another child.”
Sarah froze.
Another secret.
Of course.
“Who?”
“A son.”
“Older than me?”
“Six years.”
Sarah looked toward Michael.
He already knew.
She could see it.
“You found him.”
Michael nodded.
“His name was Jonathan.”
“Was?”
Michael lowered his eyes.
“He died.”
Sarah swallowed.
“When?”
“Twenty-seven years ago.”
Sarah did the calculation.
Jonathan would have been fifteen.
“What happened?”
Evelyn answered.
“Leukemia.”
Sarah closed her eyes.
“And I was a match?”
Evelyn nodded.
“Richard believed you might be.”
Sarah stared at her.
“You’re saying my father wanted me because I could save his son?”
“At first.”
“At first?”
Evelyn’s face crumpled.
“When testing showed you weren’t the match he wanted, he stopped seeing you as his daughter.”
Sarah felt sick.
“He wanted me dead because I couldn’t save Jonathan?”
“No.”
Evelyn shook her head.
“He wanted you gone because you were evidence.”
“Evidence of what?”
Evelyn looked at Michael.
Michael slowly removed another document from his coat.
“Sarah, Richard Hale wasn’t just your father.”
Sarah almost laughed.
“I don’t think I can survive another sentence that begins like that.”
Michael crouched beside her wheelchair.
“He was running illegal medical trials.”
Silence.
“On children.”
Sarah’s expression disappeared.
Michael continued carefully.
“He used his money to fund experimental treatments outside normal oversight. Some children became seriously ill.”
Sarah looked at Evelyn.
“And you knew?”
“Not when I married him.”
“When did you find out?”
“When I was pregnant with you.”
Evelyn’s voice trembled.
“I found records in his study. Children identified by numbers instead of names. Payments to doctors. Families being pressured into silence.”
Sarah felt nauseated.
“I threatened to expose him.”
“And?”
“He told me I’d never live long enough to do it.”
Helen finally spoke.
“That was when Evelyn came to me.”
Sarah turned toward her.
“You were a nurse.”
Helen nodded.
“At St. Matthew’s.”
Evelyn continued.
“Helen helped me during my pregnancy. She was the only person I trusted.”
“So you gave her your baby.”
“I gave her you because Richard had people watching me.”
“Why didn’t you come back?”
Evelyn started sobbing.
“I tried.”
Helen looked away.
Sarah noticed.
“What aren’t you telling me?”
Evelyn whispered:
“Six weeks after Helen disappeared with you, Richard found me.”
Sarah waited.
“He told me you were dead.”
Helen gasped.
Sarah stared at Evelyn.
“You believed him?”
“He showed me a death certificate.”
Sarah looked at Helen.
“Another lie.”
Helen nodded through tears.
“Richard had connections everywhere.”
Evelyn wiped her face.
“I spent twenty-seven years believing my daughter had died.”
Sarah’s anger faltered.
Twenty-seven years.
She understood something about that kind of grief now.
She had spent three years believing Michael was dead.
Evelyn had spent nearly three decades believing her baby was gone.
“Then how did you find out I was alive?”
Evelyn looked at Michael.
“He found me.”
Michael nodded.
“Eight months ago.”
Sarah stared at her husband.
“You’ve known for eight months?”
“Yes.”
“And you didn’t come home?”
Michael’s face collapsed.
“I couldn’t.”
“Why?”
“Because Richard Hale isn’t dead.”
Sarah froze.
Evelyn whispered:
“He was supposed to be.”
Sarah looked between them.
“What does that mean?”
Michael stood.
“Officially, Richard died twelve years ago.”
Sarah almost laughed.
“Apparently death certificates don’t mean much in this family.”
Nobody laughed.
Michael continued.
“I discovered financial transactions from accounts controlled by Richard occurring years after his supposed death.”
David stepped closer.
“So Richard faked his death too?”
“Yes.”
Sarah stared at Michael.
“And he’s the one who caused your crash?”
Michael nodded.
“I believe so.”
“Why?”
“Because I found the medical files.”
Sarah suddenly understood.
“You were going to expose him.”
“Yes.”
“And he tried to kill you.”
“Yes.”
“But David saved you.”
Michael looked at his brother.
“Yes.”
Sarah turned to David.
“Then why did both of you let me believe Michael was dead?”
David’s face filled with shame.
“Because the morning after the crash, somebody sent us a photograph.”
“What photograph?”
Michael pulled out his phone.
He showed her.
Sarah stopped breathing.
The photograph showed Sarah asleep in bed.
Lily was asleep beside her.
Taken inside their house.
The morning after Michael’s crash.
Written underneath:
HE SURVIVED. THEY DON’T HAVE TO.
Sarah covered her mouth.
Michael’s eyes filled with tears.
“I wanted to come home.”
Sarah couldn’t look at him.
“But you chose to stay dead.”
“I chose to keep you alive.”
“For three years?”
“I kept trying to find Richard.”
“And you couldn’t?”
“No.”
Sarah turned away.
She understood the fear.
But understanding didn’t erase three years of Lily crying for her father.
“Daddy?”
Everyone turned.
Lily had heard enough.
She walked toward Michael.
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
Michael knelt.
“I was trying to protect you.”
Sarah closed her eyes.
There were those words again.
Lily stared at him.
“You could’ve called.”
“I couldn’t.”
“You could’ve sent me a letter.”
“I was scared somebody would find it.”
Lily’s chin trembled.
“I thought you didn’t come home because I was bad.”
Michael’s face shattered.
“What?”
“The day you died, I got mad at you.”
“Oh, baby.”
“I told you I hated you because you wouldn’t let me have ice cream.”
Michael pulled her into his arms.
“I remembered.”
Lily started sobbing.
“Then you died.”
Michael held her tighter.
“I didn’t leave because of you.”
“I said I hated you.”
“And I knew you didn’t mean it.”
“You promise?”
“I promise.”
Lily buried her face against his chest.
Michael cried into her hair.
Sarah watched them.
For the first time since seeing him alive, some of her anger softened.
Not disappeared.
But softened.
Then Lily pulled back.
“Are you staying now?”
Michael looked at Sarah.
Sarah couldn’t answer for him.
Michael nodded.
“If your mom lets me.”
Lily looked at Sarah.
“Mommy?”
Sarah sighed.
“We have approximately nine thousand things to talk about first.”
Lily thought about it.
“Can he stay while you talk?”
Sarah looked at Michael.
“Yes.”
Michael closed his eyes.
That single word seemed to mean everything.
Then a phone rang.
Not Sarah’s.
Not Michael’s.
Helen looked down.
Her phone.
Unknown number.
She answered.
“Hello?”
A man’s voice spoke.
Helen went pale.
The phone slipped slightly in her hand.
Sarah noticed immediately.
“Who is it?”
Helen didn’t answer.
The voice came through loudly enough for everyone to hear.
“Hello, Margaret.”
Helen’s real name.
Her entire body began shaking.
Evelyn backed away.
“No.”
Sarah looked at her.
“You recognize the voice?”
Evelyn whispered:
“Richard.”
Michael immediately grabbed the phone and put it on speaker.
“Where are you?”
The man laughed.
“Michael. Still difficult to kill, I see.”
Lily grabbed Sarah’s hand.
Michael’s expression hardened.
“You’re finished.”
“Am I?”
“We have the files.”
“You have copies.”
“Enough to put you away.”
Richard laughed again.
“Then why haven’t you gone to the police?”
Michael went silent.
Sarah looked at him.
“Michael?”
Richard answered for him.
“Because your husband knows those files don’t only incriminate me.”
Sarah felt cold.
“Who else?”
“Ask Michael.”
She looked at him.
Michael couldn’t meet her eyes.
“Michael.”
“I was going to tell you.”
“Tell me what?”
Richard’s voice came through the phone.
“Ask him whose signature appears on twenty-three of those experimental treatment authorizations.”
Sarah stared at Michael.
“Whose?”
Michael whispered:
“Your father’s.”
Sarah frowned.
“Richard is my father.”
“No.”
Michael shook his head.
“The father who raised you.”
Sarah stopped.
She remembered very little of the man she’d called Dad.
Robert Bennett.
He had supposedly died when Sarah was twelve.
Another death.
Another buried history.
“What did Robert have to do with this?”
Michael looked at her.
“He was one of Richard’s doctors.”
Sarah couldn’t speak.
Helen started crying.
Sarah turned toward her.
“You married one of the men working for Richard?”
Helen whispered:
“I didn’t know at first.”
“Did anybody in my life ever tell me the truth?”
Nobody answered.
Then Richard spoke again.
“Sarah, there’s something your mother hasn’t told you.”
Sarah looked at Evelyn.
“Which mother?”
Richard laughed.
Even Sarah hated how much that laugh frightened her.
“Excellent question.”
Evelyn stepped toward the phone.
“Leave her alone.”
“After thirty-six years, that’s your opening line?”
“You’ve taken enough from her.”
“I gave her life.”
“You tried to destroy it.”
Richard’s voice hardened.
“You gave away my daughter.”
“She was never yours to own.”
Silence.
Then Richard said:
“Ask Sarah why she thinks her cancer returned now.”
Sarah felt the blood drain from her face.
Michael grabbed the phone.
“Don’t.”
Sarah looked at him.
“What does he mean?”
“Sarah—”
“What does he mean?”
Richard answered.
“Your doctors told you the cancer returned naturally.”
Sarah’s fingers tightened around the wheelchair.
“Yes.”
“They were wrong.”
Michael shouted:
“Hang up!”
Sarah grabbed his wrist.
“No.”
She looked at the phone.
“Keep talking.”
Richard sounded almost pleased.
“The private clinic treating you wasn’t only monitoring you.”
Sarah stared at Michael.
“You said they caught my cancer early.”
“They did.”
Richard continued.
“They also had access to your blood samples.”
Evelyn whispered:
“No…”
Sarah’s heart pounded.
“What are you saying?”
Richard paused.
Then:
“I’m saying someone at that clinic manipulated your medical records and exposed you to treatment you didn’t need.”
Sarah felt dizzy.
Michael crouched beside her.
“Don’t listen to him. We don’t know that yet.”
“You suspected?”
Michael couldn’t answer.
“MICHAEL!”
“Yes.”
Sarah stared at him.
“You suspected someone deliberately made me sicker?”
“We found inconsistencies.”
“And you didn’t tell me?”
“I wanted proof.”
Sarah laughed through her tears.
“Another secret to protect me.”
Michael lowered his head.
“Yes.”
Sarah looked toward the phone.
“Why would anyone do that?”
Richard’s answer came quietly.
“To bring me out of hiding.”
Everyone froze.
Sarah frowned.
“What?”
“You were bait.”
Evelyn covered her mouth.
Richard continued.
“Someone knew that if my biological daughter became seriously ill under suspicious circumstances, eventually I would investigate.”
Sarah felt sick.
“So somebody hurt me to find you?”
“Yes.”
“Who?”
For the first time, Richard hesitated.
Michael noticed.
“You don’t know.”
Richard said nothing.
“You don’t know who did it,” Michael repeated.
“No.”
Sarah looked around.
At Helen.
Evelyn.
Michael.
David.
Every person standing near her had been keeping pieces of her life from her.
Then Lily whispered:
“Mommy?”
Sarah looked down.
Lily was staring toward the parking lot.
“What is it?”
“That man is taking pictures of us.”
Michael turned immediately.
A man stood beside a silver car.
Camera raised.
When he realized they’d noticed him, he got inside.
David ran toward the parking lot.
The car accelerated away.
Michael shouted:
“Get the plate!”
David managed to photograph it.
Then Sarah heard Richard laughing through the phone.
“What?”
His laughter stopped.
“Sarah, you should leave the lake.”
“Why?”
“Now.”
Michael grabbed the phone.
“What do you know?”
Richard’s voice suddenly sounded genuinely afraid.
“That photographer doesn’t work for me.”
Sarah’s stomach dropped.
“Then who does he work for?”
“I don’t know.”
Michael looked toward the road.
“Richard.”
“Get Lily out of there.”
The call disconnected.
They left immediately.
Michael insisted they go directly to the police.
This time, Sarah agreed.
No more secret investigations.
No more protecting people through silence.
No more deciding the truth was too dangerous for someone else to know.
But halfway back to the city, Sarah became weak.
Her pain increased rapidly.
Michael looked at her surgical incision.
“We’re going back to the hospital.”
“No.”
“Sarah, you can barely stay awake.”
“Lily—”
“I’ve got her.”
David drove them straight to the emergency department.
Doctors rushed Sarah inside.
Her recent surgery had taken a greater toll than she’d admitted.
Hours later, she woke in a hospital bed.
Michael was sitting beside her.
For once, nobody was running.
Nobody was revealing another secret.
He simply held her hand.
Sarah looked at him.
“I buried you.”
“I know.”
“I hated you for dying.”
“I know.”
“I talked to you every night for a year.”
Michael started crying.
“I know.”
“How could you know?”
He reached into his pocket.
A tiny flash drive.
“I have every voicemail.”
Sarah froze.
“What?”
“You never disconnected my old number.”
Sarah remembered.
She had called Michael’s voicemail hundreds of times after his death.
Just to hear his recorded greeting.
Then she would leave messages.
Lily lost her first tooth today.
I hate you for leaving me.
I miss you.
She asked about you again.
I don’t know how to do this alone.
Sarah started crying.
“You heard them?”
“Every one.”
“And you still stayed away?”
Michael’s tears fell.
“Every message almost brought me home.”
“Why didn’t you?”
“Because every time I wanted to, I looked at that photograph of you and Lily sleeping.”
Sarah closed her eyes.
“I thought staying dead was the only way to keep you alive.”
“Were you happy?”
Michael shook his head.
“Not for one day.”
Sarah looked at him for a long time.
“I don’t know whether I can forgive you.”
“I know.”
“But Lily needs you.”
“I know.”
“And I…”
She stopped.
Michael waited.
Sarah whispered:
“I never stopped loving you.”
Michael broke down.
Neither noticed Lily standing in the doorway.
She smiled.
“Does this mean Daddy can come home?”
Sarah laughed through her tears.
“We’ll see.”
Lily ran into the room.
For a little while, there were no secrets.
Just the three of them holding each other.
The next morning, police arrived.
They had traced the photographer’s license plate.
Sarah expected another stranger.
Instead, the detective placed a photograph on the table.
“Do you recognize him?”
Sarah didn’t.
Michael did.
So did David.
Both brothers went pale.
“Who is he?” Sarah asked.
David sat down.
Michael whispered:
“That’s Dr. Andrew Cole.”
Sarah frowned.
“Cole?”
Helen’s real surname was Cole.
Sarah looked at her.
Helen stared at the photograph.
Her face collapsed.
“No.”
“Who is he?”
Helen couldn’t speak.
Sarah asked again.
“Who is Andrew Cole?”
Helen finally looked at her.
“My son.”
Sarah stopped breathing.
“You have a son?”
Helen nodded.
“Older than you.”
“Where has he been?”
“I haven’t seen him in thirty years.”
“Why?”
Helen started crying.
“Because Richard took him.”
The room went silent.
Sarah looked toward Evelyn.
“You knew?”
Evelyn shook her head.
Helen continued.
“Andrew was six when I helped Evelyn disappear with you.”
Sarah stared at her.
“Richard took your child because you took his?”
“Yes.”
“Oh my God.”
“I searched for Andrew for years.”
“What happened to him?”
Helen looked at the photograph.
“Apparently, Richard raised him.”
Michael stood.
Everything suddenly made sense.
“That’s why Andrew had access to the clinic.”
Sarah felt cold.
“The clinic where I was treated?”
Michael nodded.
Andrew Cole wasn’t merely a photographer.
He was a doctor.
A doctor connected to the medical organization that had controlled Sarah’s records.
Sarah whispered:
“Was Andrew the one who made me sick?”
Nobody answered.
Then the detective’s phone rang.
He stepped outside.
Thirty seconds later, he returned.
His expression had changed.
“What happened?” Michael asked.
“We found Andrew Cole.”
“Where?”
“At the clinic.”
Sarah gripped the blanket.
“Arrest him.”
The detective hesitated.
“We can’t.”
“Why?”
“Because he’s dead.”
Helen screamed.
Sarah stared at the detective.
“What happened?”
“Apparent suicide.”
Michael immediately shook his head.
“No.”
“How do you know?”
“Because Richard told us to leave the lake before Andrew died.”
The detective frowned.
Michael continued.
“Somebody is cleaning this up.”
Sarah felt cold.
First Michael’s crash.
Then the suspicious clinic records.
Now Andrew.
Someone was removing everyone who knew the truth.
The detective placed an evidence bag on the table.
“There was something in Dr. Cole’s pocket.”
Inside was a folded note.
Addressed to Sarah.
She opened it.
Only four lines.
Sarah,
I didn’t make you sick.
I was trying to prove who did.
Look at Lily’s original blood test. Your daughter is the key.
Sarah stared at Michael.
“What does that mean?”
Michael grabbed the old files.
They found Lily’s original newborn blood work.
Then the genetic report.
David’s paternity result.
Michael frowned.
“Something’s wrong.”
“What?”
“The blood type.”
David stepped closer.
His face changed.
“No.”
Sarah looked between them.
“What?”
David whispered:
“According to this, I can’t be Lily’s biological father.”
Sarah’s heart stopped.
“But the DNA test said you were.”
Michael looked at the report.
“Then one of these tests was falsified.”
Sarah stared at Lily through the glass wall. She was sitting outside coloring a picture.
“Why?”
Michael continued searching.
Then he found another page.
An original laboratory number.
Different from the number on the paternity report.
The detective contacted the laboratory.
The original archived result still existed.
Minutes later, an authenticated copy arrived.
Michael read it.
His face went completely white.
Sarah couldn’t stand it anymore.
“WHO IS LILY’S FATHER?”
Michael looked at her.
“It isn’t David.”
David sat down.
Sarah’s eyes filled with tears.
“Then who?”
Michael looked at the final line.
The original test didn’t identify a father.
But it contained a familial match.
A relationship Sarah had never imagined.
Michael whispered:
“Sarah… Lily’s DNA matches someone already in the database.”
“Who?”
Michael couldn’t answer.
The detective did.
“Richard Hale.”
Sarah stared at him.
“My biological father?”
“Yes.”
Sarah nearly laughed from disbelief.
“That doesn’t make sense.”
“No,” Michael said slowly.
“It doesn’t.”
Because if Richard was Sarah’s biological father, and Lily’s DNA showed the relationship indicated in the original report, there was only one explanation.
Someone had lied about Sarah’s parentage too.
Evelyn began backing toward the wall.
Sarah noticed.
“Evelyn?”
The elderly woman started crying.
“No.”
Sarah’s heart pounded.
“What haven’t you told me?”
“Please.”
“WHO IS RICHARD HALE TO ME?”
Evelyn covered her face.
Then finally whispered:
“He isn’t your father.”
Sarah felt the room tilt.
“Then who is?”
Evelyn looked toward Helen.
Helen shook her head.
“No, Evelyn.”
Sarah stared between them.
“What?”
Evelyn’s next words destroyed the final piece of the story Sarah thought she understood.
“Richard Hale wasn’t trying to kill you because you were his daughter.”
She looked at Lily through the glass.
“He wanted you hidden because you were his son’s child.”
Sarah couldn’t breathe.
“What son?”
Evelyn whispered the name.
“Andrew.”
Helen collapsed into the chair.
Sarah stared at her.
Andrew Cole.
Helen’s biological son.
The doctor who had just been found dead.
Sarah’s voice disappeared.
“You’re saying Andrew was my father?”
Evelyn nodded.
Sarah looked through the glass at Lily.
Then back at the genetic report.
“But then why does Lily’s DNA connect so strongly to Richard?”
The detective stared at the relationship calculations.
His expression changed.
“Because we’re interpreting the result from the wrong generation.”
Michael looked at him.
“What does that mean?”
The detective slowly lowered the paper.
“It means Lily isn’t showing Richard as a grandfather.”
Sarah stopped breathing.
“She is showing him as…”
He couldn’t finish.
Then Sarah’s phone rang.
Unknown number.
Michael answered.
“Who is this?”
A woman’s voice spoke.
“Put Sarah on.”
Sarah took the phone.
“Hello?”
The woman was crying.
“My name is Dr. Laura Hale.”
Sarah closed her eyes.
“What do you want?”
“To tell you why Andrew died.”
Sarah’s heart pounded.
“Who killed him?”
The woman whispered:
“The same person who falsified Lily’s paternity test nine years ago.”
“Who?”
Laura’s next sentence left everyone silent.
“Sarah, David isn’t Lily’s biological father.”
Sarah squeezed her eyes shut.
“I know.”
“But neither is Michael.”
“I know that too.”
“No.”
Laura began crying.
“You still don’t understand.”
“Then tell me!”
The woman took a trembling breath.
“Lily’s biological father is Richard Hale.”
Sarah stopped breathing.
The man she’d spent the last day believing was her father.
The man who had stalked her family for decades.
The man connected to her childhood medical records.
Richard Hale.
Sarah’s voice came out as a whisper.
“That is impossible.”
Laura answered:
“No, Sarah.”
Then she revealed the truth that made Michael drop the phone.
“Because Lily isn’t your biological daughter.”
Sarah stared through the glass.
At the little girl she’d carried home.
The little girl she’d raised for eight years.
The little girl who called her Mommy.
And suddenly the oldest question in Sarah’s story wasn’t who her parents were.
It was:
Who were Lily’s?
One Comment on “The night before her cancer surgery, Sarah couldn’t sleep 😢”